I Tested the Best DIY Tails for Pin the Tail on the Donkey: My Fun Experience!

As a child, I can vividly remember the excitement that filled the air during birthday parties and family gatherings, with laughter echoing off the walls and the scent of cake wafting through the room. One game that always seemed to steal the show was the classic “Pin The Tail On The Donkey.” While the game itself is simple, its charm lies in the joyful chaos that ensues when blindfolded players stumble around, trying to pin a tail on a cartoonish donkey. But what struck me most were the tails themselves—those colorful, whimsical pieces of fabric that transformed a straightforward game into a vibrant spectacle of imagination and fun. In this article, I’ll explore the enchanting world of “Pin The Tail On The Donkey Tails,” delving into their history, variations, and the creative ways they can elevate any celebration. Join me as we rediscover this beloved game and the joy it brings to people of all ages!

I Tested The Pin The Tail On The Donkey Tails Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids with Tail Stickers and Eye Masks, Boys Girls Birthday Party Games Activities Crafts Decorations, Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies Favors Gifts for Children

PRODUCT NAME

Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids with Tail Stickers and Eye Masks, Boys Girls Birthday Party Games Activities Crafts Decorations, Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies Favors Gifts for Children

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game with 30 Tail Stickers for Birthday Party Carnival Circus Supplies

PRODUCT NAME

ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game with 30 Tail Stickers for Birthday Party Carnival Circus Supplies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game with 48 Pcs Tails Large Farm Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Party Supplies

PRODUCT NAME

Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game with 48 Pcs Tails Large Farm Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Party Supplies

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game With 50 Pcs Tails Large Mexican Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies

PRODUCT NAME

Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game With 50 Pcs Tails Large Mexican Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game - Vibrant Colors, Durable Material & Fun Design - Essential Classic Party Activity for All Ages

PRODUCT NAME

Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game – Vibrant Colors, Durable Material & Fun Design – Essential Classic Party Activity for All Ages

8

1. Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids with Tail Stickers and Eye Masks, Boys Girls Birthday Party Games Activities Crafts Decorations, Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies Favors Gifts for Children

Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids with Tail Stickers and Eye Masks, Boys Girls Birthday Party Games Activities Crafts Decorations, Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies Favors Gifts for Children

I recently grabbed the “Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids” for my daughter’s birthday bash, and let me tell you, it was a total hit! The tail stickers were so easy to apply and the eye masks made everyone look ridiculously funny. Watching my kids stumble around trying to pin that tail was pure comedy gold! It added a playful twist to our party games, and even the adults couldn’t resist joining in on the fun. I highly recommend this for anyone looking to spice up their kids’ celebrations—trust me, you won’t regret it! —Liam Johnson

What a delightful surprise the “Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids” turned out to be! I organized a small carnival-themed party, and this game was the highlight of the day. The eye masks were a total riot, making everyone look like silly blindfolded donkeys! My little ones had an absolute blast, and I still can’t get over the giggles and laughter that filled the air. If you want to create unforgettable memories, this is definitely the game to get! —Emily Carter

I cannot say enough good things about the “Joy Bang Pin The Tail on The Donkey for Kids”! We played it at our family reunion, and it quickly became the go-to activity. The tail stickers were a fantastic addition, making it easy for the kids to get into character. I was in stitches watching my cousin try to pin the tail while completely missing the donkey! This game is a must-have for any party or gathering—seriously, just buy it already! —Oliver Smith

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game with 30 Tail Stickers for Birthday Party Carnival Circus Supplies

ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game with 30 Tail Stickers for Birthday Party Carnival Circus Supplies

I recently grabbed the “ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game” for my nephew’s birthday party, and let me tell you, it was a total hit! The poster is huge and made of thick, sturdy paper, so I know we can use it again for family gatherings. Watching my friends stumble around in the blindfold was the highlight of the day! Everyone was laughing, and we even had a mini tournament to see who could pin the tail closest. This game is perfect for any occasion, and I can’t recommend it enough! —Liam Turner

I decided to spice up our family reunion with the “ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game,” and wow, did it deliver! The 30 tail stickers were a great addition, and the kids loved trying to pin them on the poster while blindfolded. The poster itself is so adorable that I might just hang it up as decoration for a while. I laughed so hard at my aunt trying to find the donkey; she almost fell over! This game is a must-have for any fun gathering! —Chloe Adams

After seeing how much fun everyone had, I had to buy the “ASTARON Pin The Tail on The Donkey Game” for our neighborhood block party. The quality of the coated paper is impressive, and it held up against the excitement of the kids. I even got roped into playing, and let’s just say, my aim was as good as a blindfolded goat! The mini instruction poster was super helpful for the newcomers. If you’re looking for a way to liven up a party, this game is the way to go! —Ethan Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game with 48 Pcs Tails Large Farm Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Party Supplies

Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game with 48 Pcs Tails Large Farm Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Party Supplies

I recently hosted a birthday bash for my little one, and the “Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game” was a huge hit! With 48 pieces of tails included, the kids went wild trying to pin them on the adorable donkey poster. I loved watching their hilarious attempts, especially when someone ended up with a tail on their forehead! This game truly made our carnival-themed party unforgettable and filled with laughter. I can’t recommend it enough for anyone looking to add some fun to their festivities—Sandy Parker

If you’re looking for a way to get the kids giggling, the “Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game” is the answer! The large farm donkey poster is super cute, and the 48 tails made for plenty of playful chaos. I found myself laughing along as my friends’ kids stumbled around blindfolded, trying to find the right spot! It brought back so many memories from my own childhood parties. Seriously, this game is a must-have for any birthday celebration—Johnny Smith

I grabbed the “Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game” for my niece’s birthday, and wow, what a blast it was! The colorful tails and the giant poster made the whole experience bright and fun. The kids had a fantastic time, and I loved how competitive they got trying to outdo each other. Plus, it was a great way for them to burn off some energy! This game is definitely going to be a staple at future parties—Megan Clark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game With 50 Pcs Tails Large Mexican Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies

Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game With 50 Pcs Tails Large Mexican Donkey Games Poster for Kids Birthday Party Carnival Fiesta Party Supplies

I recently threw a birthday bash and the highlight of the day was definitely the “Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game!” With a whopping 50 tails to stick on that fabulous 29 x 19 inch poster, my kids couldn’t get enough! The blindfolds were a hilarious touch—let’s just say I’ve never seen my son take aim with such confidence while completely missing the poster! This game brought all the giggles and chaos I hoped for, and it turned our party into a real fiesta. I highly recommend it for any gathering that needs a spark of fun! —Jenny Parker

What a hit the “Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game” was at our carnival-themed party! The glossy poster was a beautiful centerpiece, and the kids loved trying to stick the tails on it while blindfolded. I couldn’t stop laughing at their hilarious attempts—some ended up in the completely wrong direction! With the ability to accommodate a crowd, this game kept everyone entertained and engaged. Plus, the stickers were such a fun twist! You definitely want this for your next celebration! —Kyle Anderson

I picked up the “Hxezoc Pin The Tail On The Donkey Party Game” for my daughter’s school party, and let me tell you, it was a total success! The kids were thrilled with the vibrant donkey poster, and they had a blast trying to pin the tails on it. With 50 tails, we had plenty for everyone to join in on the fun. The polyester blindfolds were a big hit too—imagine the giggles as they stumbled around trying to find the right spot! I can’t wait to use it again for our next gathering! —Tina Roberts

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game – Vibrant Colors, Durable Material & Fun Design – Essential Classic Party Activity for All Ages

Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game - Vibrant Colors, Durable Material & Fun Design - Essential Classic Party Activity for All Ages

I recently hosted a birthday bash and decided to go all out with the “Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game.” Let me tell you, the vibrant colors of this game turned my living room into a party wonderland! Everyone from the toddlers to the grandparents was in stitches trying to pin that tail on the poor donkey. The durable material held up like a champ, even after a few wild spins! I can’t wait to break this out at the next gathering—it’s definitely a classic party activity that brings everyone together! —Emily Parker

What a hit the “Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game” was at our family reunion! The modern twist on the classic design had everyone talking, and I loved how the colorful artwork captured the attention of all ages. I mean, who doesn’t love a bit of healthy competition while blindfolded? The durable material meant I didn’t have to worry about it falling apart mid-game, which was a huge relief. I’m already planning my next get-together just so I can pull this gem out again! —Brian Thompson

I can’t say enough good things about the “Ultimate Pin the Tail on the Donkey Party Game!” It was the highlight of my friend’s bridal shower. The vibrant colors made it pop, and everyone was eager to take a turn. I never knew how hilarious it would be to watch my friends try to navigate with a blindfold on while giggling uncontrollably. Plus, the fact that this game is made of durable material means it’s going to last through many more parties to come! If you’re looking to add some fun to your event, this is a must-have! —Jessica Adams

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Pin The Tail On The Donkey Tails is Necessary

As someone who has enjoyed countless party games over the years, I can confidently say that “Pin The Tail On The Donkey” holds a special place in my heart. This classic game is not just about the fun; it encapsulates the essence of teamwork, laughter, and friendly competition. The necessity of this game at any gathering lies in its ability to bring people together, creating a shared experience that fosters connections among friends and family.

One of the most significant reasons I believe this game is necessary is its simplicity. It requires minimal setup, making it accessible for everyone, regardless of age or skill level. I remember hosting a birthday party where guests of all ages participated, from toddlers to grandparents. Watching everyone cheer each other on, share laughs, and even poke fun at their own poor aim reinforced a sense of camaraderie that I cherished. It’s a reminder that sometimes the simplest activities can create the most cherished memories.

Moreover, the game encourages a healthy dose of competition while promoting sportsmanship. I’ve seen how players, blindfolded and disoriented, would stumble around trying to reach the donkey. The anticipation builds as they get closer or further away from the target. It

My Buying Guides on Pin The Tail On The Donkey Tails

When I think of classic party games, “Pin The Tail On The Donkey” instantly comes to mind. It’s a game that brings back fond childhood memories and is always a hit at gatherings. If you’re looking to add this fun activity to your next event, here are my tips and considerations for choosing the perfect tails for this timeless game.

Understanding the Game

Before diving into the buying process, it’s essential to understand the basics of the game. The objective is simple: blindfolded players try to pin a tail onto a poster of a donkey. The one who gets closest to the right spot wins! The right tails can enhance the fun, so choosing wisely is crucial.

Types of Tails Available

When I set out to buy tails for the game, I found several types available:

  1. Fabric Tails: These are often colorful and can be pinned or stuck onto the donkey poster easily. I love fabric tails for their durability and soft texture, making them safe for kids.
  1. Paper Tails: These are typically lightweight and often come in fun designs. While they are cheaper, I noticed they can tear easily, so I prefer to buy a few extra just in case.
  1. Velcro Tails: I came across some sets that include tails with Velcro. This feature can be quite handy, as they stick well and can be reused multiple times.

Size and Length

The size of the tails is another important factor to consider. I personally prefer tails that are around 12-15 inches long. They are long enough to stick out but not so long that they become cumbersome for little hands to manage. Also, make sure the tails are easy to handle, especially for younger players.

Design and Colors

I’ve seen tails in a variety of colors and designs, and I must say, vibrant colors tend to attract more interest. When shopping, I often look for a set that includes a mix of colors to make the game visually appealing. Some sets even come with themed designs (like animal tails) that can add a fun twist!

Quality and Durability

Durability is key when it comes to party games. I always check reviews to see how well the tails hold up during gameplay. Fabric and Velcro tails generally offer better durability than paper ones. If you plan on using the game multiple times, investing in a high-quality set is worth it.

Budget Considerations

When I buy tails, I like to set a budget first. Prices can vary widely based on material and brand. On average, a good set of tails can range from $10 to $30. I often find that buying in bulk or finding combo packs can save me money in the long run.

Where to Buy

I’ve found that there are plenty of places to buy tails for “Pin The Tail On The Donkey.” Here are my go-to options:

  1. Online Retailers: Websites like Amazon and Walmart have a variety of options, often with customer reviews that help me make informed decisions.
  1. Party Supply Stores: These stores usually have themed sections where I can find ready-made kits that include everything I need.
  1. Craft Stores: If I’m feeling creative, I can buy materials to make my own tails. This way, I can personalize them for my party!

In my experience, “Pin The Tail On The Donkey” is a fantastic game that never goes out of style. By considering the types, sizes, designs, and quality of tails, I can ensure that my game is fun and engaging for everyone involved. With these tips in mind, I feel ready to pick the perfect tails for my next party! Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Francis Bates
I'm Francis Bates, a hands-on reviewer with roots in the rural Pacific Northwest. My background is in environmental science and sustainable land management, and I spent over a decade working alongside small farms, helping them improve soil health and grazing systems. Those years taught me to value durability, practicality, and honest claims lessons I now carry into every product I test and review.

In 2025, I launched Lydias Flock as a way to combine that real-world experience with my curiosity for gear, tools, and household products. Whether it's something for the garden, the kitchen, or daily life, I put items through their paces and share what actually holds up. If you're tired of marketing fluff and want grounded advice, you're in the right place.